« April 2008 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30
You are not logged in. Log in
Entries by Topic
All topics  «
Ye Old Word Smithy
Friday, 18 April 2008
Fiction, a tricky word

Since this is a writing site, it is probably time consider that much-worn word, fiction.

 

The word apparently came into being in late Middle English, borrowed from Old French, where, in turn, it had been lifted from the Latin, fictio (noun), and fingere (verb).

 

I have heard several writers call themselves liars, a concept I find somewhat unsettling. But the fact remains, fiction writers make stories up, To do so, they use invented people (characters) and invented events (plots & sticky situations). Thus, writers present "fiction" as opposed to "fact."

 

So to separate writers from liars, some say, it matters whether one "makes up" stories to deceive or to entertain. If it's the latter, you're working in fictional prose; if it's the former, well, shame on you.

 

However, to be able entertain readers, writers must get readers to "suspend disbelief." So writers must make their work seem as real as possible, pushing most of us, in the end, to employ techniques or tricks which qualify as outright deceptions. Ugh.

 

After all, we must remember that fiction's antonym is fact.

 

Best wishes

Anna Drake


Posted by Anna Drake at 8:13 AM CDT

Tuesday, 29 April 2008 - 8:39 AM CDT

Name: "Morningjoy"
Home Page: http://http//:morningjoy.wordpress.com

It seems to me that writing is an art. One of dictionary.com's definitions for art is: "skilled workmanship, execution, or agency, as distinguished from nature".  I remember when I first heard of using Photoshop to alter photographs. The idea upset me, because it seemed like creating a falsehood--a lie. Now, years later, I enjoy using that very program to make my photos into pieces of art. I guess it's like that with writing fiction. As long as we're not representing fiction as fact, it' a piece of artistry.  The magic of fiction is that the impossible, or at least the unlikely, becomes possible. That's what makes it a creation, rather than just a representation.

Saturday, 19 July 2008 - 11:09 PM CDT

Name: "Cynthia"
Home Page: http://waltzingaustralia.wordpress.com

Well, actually, the opposite of fiction is nonfiction. Lots of fiction contains facts (real locations, real events), and much fiction presents truth, often in a more accessible way than nonfiction does. This is, for example, why Jesus taught using parables.

You don't give the definition of the old Latin, but it is "to shape, to form." So the word refers to a creative process.

I think you were most accurate when you defined the difference as being one of intention. The liar knows something is untrue but tells it as if it were true, with the intention of deceiving. The fiction writer "shapes" a story in order to entertain or even convey truth in some form. The reader may suspend disbelief, but there should be no doubt that something is fiction. Of course, there are writers who do lie, but that's different from being simply a good story teller.

So I don't think you have to worry about being a liar just because you write fiction. You're simply carrying on a tradition as old as language.

View Latest Entries